Many or all of the products featured on this page are from our sponsors who compensate us. This may influence which products we write about and where and how the product appears on a page. However, this does not influence our evaluations. Our opinions are our own. Here is a list of our partners and here is how we make money.
The information provided on this page is for educational purposes only. The Modest Wallet is a financial publisher that does not offer any personal financial advice or advocate the purchase or sale of any security or investment for any specific individual.
Stash and Acorns are both passive-investing platforms through which retail investors can build their portfolios. The main difference between the two is that Acorns is a robo-advisor and Stash facilitates fractional share purchases and helps investors diversify their holdings adequately.
With roughly 10 million users combined, these two platforms have been disrupting the asset management industry in the United States for more than five years and you can use the following review to compare them before you pick the one that you’ll go with.
Stash vs. Acorns: Overview
Although Stash and Acorns both offer a low-cost passive investing service, these investing apps are different in how they assist customers in portfolio building.
|In A Nutshell||Stash is a subscription-based investment platform that offers fractional shares and ETFs for investors in the United States, with zero trading fees involved. Stash offers various plans with monthly fees starting at just $1.||Acorns can be categorized as a one-stop-shop for all things personal finance. They offer a wide variety of financial products related to banking, retirement planning, and investment management for as low as $1 per month.|
|Our Review||Full Stash Review||Full Acorns Review|
Stash was founded in 2015 as an alternative to traditional asset managers, who charged high fees for investors who had a small account balance.
The firm currently serves approximately five million customers in the United States by providing them with access to taxable and tax-deferred accounts, fractional shares, and zero-commission trades to build their portfolios.
Read our full Stash review to learn more.
Launched in 2012, Acorns is considered an automated passive investing platform through which investors can build a portfolio without having to commit any time to doing so. This is achieved through the combination of complex algorithms and a time-tested investing strategy to set up a portfolio for them.
In a similar way to Stash, Acorns also offers both taxable and tax-deferred accounts along with five different portfolio choices for virtually any type of investor regardless of their age, risk tolerance, or income.
Both of these firms charge a monthly subscription to provide their services but their prices and features are different.
Check out our full Acorns review to learn more.
Stash vs. Acorns: Main Features
The following is an overview that covers the main features offered by each of these providers including their investing, banking, and retirement solutions.
|Fees||$1 per month (Stash Beginner), $3 per month (Stash Growth) and $9 per month (Stash+)||$1 per month (Lite), $3 per month (Personal) and $5 per month (Family)|
|Investment Types||Stocks and ETFs||Stocks and ETFs|
|Account Types||Individual Taxable, Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, and Custodial Account||Individual Taxable, Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, SEP IRA and Custodial Account|
|Platforms||Mobile (iOS and Android)||Mobile (iOS and Android)|
|Promotions||Get a $5 welcome bonus||Get $5 when you sign up|
|Socially Responsible Investing|
|Access to Financial Advice|
|Best For||DIY Passive Investors||Passive Investors|
Stash provides its services through three different subscription plans that give users access to various features offered by the firm.
The Stash Beginner plan gives investors access to the firm’s passive investing platform and thousands of US-listed stocks and exchange-traded funds (ETFs).
These instruments can be purchased without incurring a commission or trading fee and the user will also get access to unlimited financial advice and educational resources.
Additionally, investors will receive a Stock-Back® debit card after opening a bank account provided by the firm. Through the firm’s rewards program, users are entitled to receive compensation in the form of fractional shares for any purchases they make.
Meanwhile, the Stash Growth plan adds the possibility of opening or rolling over an individual retirement account (IRA) or a Roth IRA, both of which are tax-deferred accounts.
Moreover, Growth users will also have access to personalized advice from a qualified Stash team member who can help them in planning for their retirement.
Finally, the premium plan, called Stash+, goes one step further by enabling users to open two investment accounts for their kids while doubling the rewards generated by the company’s Visa™ debit card.
It is important to note that fractional shares can be bought for as little as $1 with this provider while its banking products are offered by Green Dot Bank. All accounts are FDIC-insured and withdrawals are free if they are made by using one of the 19,000 ATMs within their network.
Main Features Overview
- Three subscription plans to choose from: Each plan provides users with access to the different features offered by Stash.
- Zero-commission trades: Stash users can enjoy buying and selling the instruments within their portfolios without incurring any charges.
- Fractional shares: Investors can build diversified portfolios regardless of the balance on their accounts by using fractional shares.
- Unlimited financial advice and educational resources: These resources can be quite helpful in areas such as portfolio design, risk management, and others.
- Low-cost banking solution: Stash’s bank account is an FDIC-insured product that allows the holder to receive rewards in the form of stocks.
- Investment guidance: Stash’s main goal is to make investing accessible to everyone. Through the setup process, the app asks new account holders some questions to determine their goals and risk tolerance. The app then selects a few ETFs that would make sense for the investor’s particular situation.
- Custodial accounts: Investors can use these accounts to save up and invest for their kids’ future by using the same strategies and platform they will use for their retirement or taxable investment accounts.
- Smart Portfolio: A new feature offered by Stash to help users build long-term wealth and diversify their investment portfolios. Stash will create and managed a fully diversified portfolio based on the user’s financial risk profile, time horizon, and goals. Stash will automatically rebalance your portfolio if the asset allocation deviates by more than 5% from the original asset mix.
Acorns provides an automated passive-investing service, also known as a robo-advisor, which relies on algorithms to determine the most suitable portfolios for each investor based on their income, job situation, risk tolerance, and financial goals.
The firm’s investing service relies on a time-tested investing methodology backed by Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT) along with the use of low-cost exchange-traded funds (ETFs) to build, maintain, and rebalance its client’s portfolios efficiently.
Currently, Acorns offers a selection of five different portfolios going from Conservative (100% bonds) to Aggressive (100% stocks) and each investor will get a recommendation on which of the portfolios is the most suitable for their particular situation upon answering a set of questions.
Same as with Stash, investors pay a monthly subscription fee to use the company’s services with three different plans to choose from: Lite, Personal, and Family.
Each of these plans gives the user access to the different features offered by the company, which include banking, retirement, and cash management solutions.
The firm’s retirement planning feature, known as Acorns Later, gives Personal and Family users the possibility of opening an IRA, Roth IRA, SEP-IRA, or roll over their current 401(k), to be administered by the robo-advisor.
Meanwhile, the company also offers a banking product called Acorns Spend, which consists of an FDIC-insured savings account provided by Lincoln Savings Bank that comes with a tungsten metal Visa™ debit card and generates zero fees for holders.
Other programs include Acorns Early, which provides custodial accounts for children–also managed by the robo-advisor–and Acorns Earn, a rewards program that entitles Acorns’ users to receive rewards in the form of stocks for making purchases within a network of more than 350 different affiliated brands and vendors.
Main Features Overview
- Inexpensive automated passive-investing service: Acorns’ subscription-based service gives investors the possibility of having their portfolios managed professionally without having to pay hefty fees.
- Round-ups: Users can link their Acorns’ debit card or third-party card to enjoy this feature, which consists of depositing the change left over after a disbursement is made into the investment account once the amount reaches $5.
- Customized portfolios for each type of investor: The five portfolios offered by Acorns cover virtually all types of investors that exist based on their financial goals and risk tolerance.
- Banking and retirement solutions: Acorns Spend (banking) is a cheap bank account that entitles the holder to rewards from a network of vendors while Acorns Later (retirement) provides retirement planning services through a portfolio management solution that relies on the firm’s robo-advisor.
- Competitive subscription fees: Acorns plans are cheaper than those offered by Stash, with the basic plan (Lite) starting at $1 per month while the premium package (Family) costs $4 per month.
Stash vs. Acorns: Investment Options
Both Stash and Acorns are considered passive-investing long-term platforms, which means that they are not designed for self-directed day traders or high-frequency traders.
Different from Acorns, Stash’s platform does not provide any kind of advice with regards to which securities users should pick for their individual portfolios.
That said, Stash does offer the possibility of buying and selling thousands of US-listed stocks, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), and American Depositary Receipts (ADRs) either directly or through fractional shares.
Fractional shares entitle the holder to a portion of the underlying stock.
Acorns’ portfolios are built by using low-cost exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that hold a basket of instruments of a certain asset class.
Acorns does not allow its users to place individual trades or build their portfolios on their own.
Stash vs. Acorns: Account Types
Both of these providers offer the possibility of opening taxable and tax-deferred accounts, which makes them a very appealing alternative for passive investors.
Stash currently offers the following types of accounts:
- Individual taxable accounts
- Joint taxable accounts
- Online debit accounts
- IRA & Roth IRA
- Custodial account
Acorns currently supports the following types of accounts for its investors:
- Individual taxable account
- Traditional IRA
- Roth IRA
- SEP IRA
- Custodial account
Stash vs. Acorns: Sign Up Bonuses and Promotions
Stash and Acorns offer two forms of rewards: sign-up bonuses and referral bonuses.
Users can enjoy a $5 Welcome Bonus by signing up with Stash through the link provided below.
Additionally, there is an extra $5 reward for getting your friends to join Stash as well.
Users can get up to $10 in rewards from Acorns by opening an account with this provider through the link provided below.
Additionally, this provider also offers rewards for getting your friends to join the platform.
Stash vs. Acorns: Fees & Pricing
In terms of pricing, Acorns beats Stash as its subscription fees are lower for the premium tier.
- Stash Beginner: $1 per month, gives users access to the investing platform along with the banking solution.
- Stash Growth: $3 per month, allows users to open or rollover a retirement account while giving them access to personalized financial advice from the firm’s team.
- Stash+: $9 per month, gives users access to all the features mentioned above along with the possibility of opening two investment accounts for their kids and twice the rewards they would normally obtain through the Stock-Back® debit card.
- Acorns Lite: $1 per month, gives users access to the firm’s robo-advisor along with the rewards program.
- Acorns Personal: $3 per month, allows users to open a retirement account along with the firm’s banking solutions (savings and checking accounts).
- Acorns Family: $4 per month, gives users access to all the programs offered by Acorns including the ones mentioned above and the Early program for custodial accounts.
Stash vs. Acorns: What We Like (Pros)
Between these two, Stash is perhaps the one that offers less of an edge compared to other providers. Acorns, on the other hand, has a lot to offer for a relatively low price.
- US-based, regulated investing platform
- More than five million users are currently being served.
- Access to thousands of US-listed stocks and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) either directly or through fractional shares
- Zero-commission trades
- Unlimited financial advice and educational resources for both basic and premium users
- The subscription-based model is fairly cheap for individuals with an account balance higher than $20,000
- The firm’s custodial accounts are a great tool for family planning
- Stock-back rewards are an interesting way of progressively building up the account’s balance
- US-based regulated investing firm
- Over $1 billion in assets under management and more than 5 million users
- Acorns’ robo-advisor eliminates the effort of building a portfolio from scratch
- Time-tested investing methodology that yields positive results with little volatility over long holding periods
- Vast network of affiliated brands that offer rewards for each purchase made
- The round-up feature allows investors to save seemingly small amounts of money that can turn into interesting sums once invested over time
- Pricing structure is highly competitive for investors whose portfolio is valued above $10,000
Stash vs. Acorns: What We Don’t Like (Cons)
With the good also comes the bad. Make sure you check out where both Stash and Acorns fall short.
- Stash is a self-directed investing platform, which creates the burden of having to build a portfolio from scratch for individuals who are commonly not professionally trained to do so.
- Stash’s pricing structure makes it an expensive solution for individuals with a balance smaller than $20,000 if they wish to enroll in the Stash+ program.
- Acorns services are cheaper while they provide the added benefit of having a robo-advisor build the portfolio.
- The company does not allow any form of self-directed investing or trading.
- Acorns services can be expensive compared to rivals like Betterment if the investor has a portfolio balance lower than $10,000.
Stash vs. Acorns: Security
Both Stash and Acorns come equipped with standard security features you would expect from reputable online brokers.
Stash is a heavily-regulated US investing platform. The firm’s operations are overseen by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA).
Additionally, Stash is a member of SIPC, an institution that provides coverage for up to $500,000 in securities held within the firm’s investment accounts including $250,000 in cash.
Finally, Stash banking products are offered by the Green Dot Bank, a financial institution that is a member of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC). This gives the bank accounts held with this provider coverage for up to $250,000 per customer in case the bank ceases to operate.
Acorns is also a US-based highly regulated institution overseen by FINRA and the SEC while they are also members of SIPC, which means the accounts enjoy the same $500,000 coverage.
On the other hand, the bank accounts offered by Acorns are provided by the Lincoln Savings Bank, a financial institution that is also a member of the FDIC, which means that clients also enjoy the $250,000 of coverage provided to the accounts.
Stash vs. Acorns: Platform and App
Both Stash and Acorns’ platforms are designed with beginner investors in mind.
They are considered to be very user-friendly and they have a set of features that allow users to track their progress toward their financial goals while also allowing them to check their account balance and the status of their accounts.
Stash offers a web-based platform and a mobile app supported by both Android and iOS devices.
The app was given a 4.1-star rating in Google’s Play Store by a total of 51,594 users. The app also received a 4.7-star rating on Apple’s App Store from more than 205,000 users.
Acorns also offers both a web-based version and a mobile app for both Android and iOS devices.
The iOS version was granted 4.7 stars in Apple’s App Store with over 666,000 opinions submitted by users, while the Android version has received a 4.4 stars rating in Google’s Play Store with more than 132,000 votes.
Who Is Stash For?
Stash is an interesting alternative for people who prefer to be in charge of their investments, as they offer zero-commission trades and portfolio management features that are very useful for passive, long-term investors.
On the other hand, having access to fractional shares allows users to build a broadly diversified portfolio that includes high-priced stocks that would otherwise be out of reach.
Meanwhile, the firm’s banking products and rewards program are very interesting from a cash management perspective as users can benefit from the Stock-Back® feature to keep building their account balance over time.
Other features, such as custodial accounts and retirement planning, are also interesting from a family planning perspective.
Who Is Acorns For?
Acorns is a great alternative for investors who prefer to let professionals handle their investments as the robo-advisor can quickly choose which portfolio fits the client’s goals and risk tolerance best.
Meanwhile, the company’s low subscription fees compared to Stash makes it a great pick for passive investors as long as they don’t want to get involved in the process of building the portfolio.
Finally, Acorns’ rewards program has incorporated some of the most widely recognized brands and vendors and investors can benefit from the offers they push through the platform in the form of stock-based or even cash rewards in some cases.
Stash and Acorns are both passive investing platforms through which individuals in the United States can build their wealth and retirement portfolios thanks to innovative products and services like fractional shares and automated portfolio builders–a.k.a. robo-advisors.
However, although they both offer similar services, their pricing structure and the way they handle investments (one self-directed and the other automated) make them very different animals, and investors should be aware of these differences before deciding which of them to go with.
- Stash Review: Invest with as Little as $5
- Acorns Review: Is This the Best Micro-Investing App?
- 12 Best Online Brokers for Stock Trading
- 7 Best Micro-Investing Apps
- 12 Best Robo-Advisors: Automate Your Investments
Get our free Stock Market Playbook to learn how to invest your first $500 in the stock market.
Plus our best money tips delivered straight to your inbox.
Alejandro is a financial writer with 7 years of experience in financial management and financial analysis. He writes technical content about economics, finance, investments, and real estate and has also assisted financial businesses in building their digital marketing strategy. His favorite topics are value investing and financial analysis.